When an Italian life insurance policy names as beneficiaries, in general terms, the “statutory heirs” (eredi legittimi) or the “testamentary heirs” (eredi testamentari), the payout is not divided like the estate. Whoever receives it acquires a right of their own against the insurer: the beneficiaries are identified at the time of death, even if they later renounce the inheritance, and, unless the policyholder clearly wanted otherwise, they receive equal shares, not their shares of the estate.
These are the principles laid down by the Joint Divisions (Sezioni Unite) of the Italian Court of Cassation in judgment no. 11421 of 30 April 2021, which the Third Civil Section applied in 2026 to two concrete cases: beneficiaries who died before the brother who had taken out the policy, and a designation of the “testamentary heirs or, failing them, the statutory heirs” that had to be read in the light of the will. Here is who is paid, in what shares and what to check.
01
The policy payout is not part of the estate
Under Italian law a beneficiary may be designated in the policy itself, by a later written statement notified to the insurer, or by will, and the designation is valid even if the beneficiary is identified only in general terms (art. 1920 of the Civil Code). Through the designation the beneficiary acquires a right of their own to the benefits of the insurance: the money does not pass through the estate and is not divided under the rules of succession.
Two practical consequences follow. First, sums owed by the insurer to the beneficiary cannot be subjected to enforcement or interim attachment (art. 1923(1) of the Civil Code). Second, as regards the premiums paid, the rules protecting creditors against prejudicial acts and those on bringing gifts into account, imputation and reduction of gifts still apply (art. 1923(2)). In a dispute over the reserved share of close family members (quota di legittima), it is therefore the premiums paid, not the payout, that enter the calculation.
02
Who the “heirs” named in the policy are
According to the Joint Divisions, as the two 2026 decisions recall, the word “heirs” is there to give the insurer a reliable criterion for identifying whom to pay. The beneficiaries are those who, at the time of the policyholder’s death, qualify as heirs under the title indicated in the contract: the law, if the policy refers to statutory heirs, or the will, if it refers to testamentary heirs (Court of Cassation, Civil Section III, judgment of 20 April 2026, no. 10382).
The criterion does not depend on who actually inherits. A person who is a statutory heir in the abstract remains a beneficiary even if they renounce the inheritance: they may, for example, renounce an estate burdened with debts and still collect the policy. Who the statutory heirs are, and in what order, is set by the Italian Civil Code; for a spouse with children, for instance, the spouse takes one third of the estate when there are two or more children (art. 581).
The Court has also set a limit: a clause in favour of the “statutory heirs” does not include relatives who had already died before the policy was taken out, because a designation presupposes that the beneficiary is alive when it is made. In that case the payout is not divided “by branches” (per stirpi) among their descendants (Court of Cassation no. 5986 of 2025, recalled by Civil Section III, order of 8 June 2026, no. 18633).
04
If a beneficiary dies before the policyholder
When a beneficiary dies before the policyholder, the benefit must be paid to the beneficiary’s heirs, provided it has not been revoked and the policyholder has not provided otherwise (art. 1412(2) of the Civil Code). The heirs of the predeceased beneficiary do not receive a share of their own: they step into the share that would have gone to him or her.
That is what the Court of Cassation decided in order no. 18633 of 8 June 2026. An unmarried man with no children had taken out a policy in 2004 in favour of his “statutory heirs” and died in 2015 without a will. When the policy was taken out, his six brothers and sisters were all alive; by the time of his death three had died, and their children had become heirs by representation (rappresentazione). The insurer had divided the payout into nine equal parts, one for each heir, and the Court of Appeal had upheld its approach.
The Court of Cassation set that judgment aside: the siblings who died after the policy was taken out were beneficiaries, and their children acquire the right as their heirs, in the amount that would have gone to their parent. The payout therefore had to be divided into six shares, one for each sibling, with the share of each predeceased sibling split among his or her children. The case went back to the Salerno Court of Appeal to calculate the amounts.
05
“Testamentary heirs or, failing them, statutory heirs”: the will decides
Many Italian policies use the wording “testamentary heirs or, failing them, statutory heirs”. Where there is a will, it has to be interpreted to identify the beneficiaries, and the decisive question is whether a person was appointed heir or merely legatee. An heir (erede) receives the whole estate or a fraction of it; a person who receives specific assets is a legatee (legatario), unless the testator meant those assets as a share of the estate (art. 588 of the Civil Code).
In the case decided by judgment no. 10382 of 20 April 2026, after a public hearing ordered because of the particular importance of the question, a man had left almost all his estate, debts included, to his children and, within the freely disposable share, “the remaining cash” in a bank account to his sisters. The sisters claimed the policy payout as testamentary heirs. The Florence Court of Appeal had found that they were legatees, and therefore not beneficiaries, and the Court of Cassation dismissed their appeal: what counts in classifying a provision is its actual content, more than the words used, such as “disposable share”.
In the case before it, the Court read the wording “testamentary heirs or, failing them, statutory heirs” as the policyholder’s choice to keep, through his will, the power to decide who would collect the policy. That is why the policy and the will must be coordinated: a provision written with the estate in mind can also decide, without the testator realising it, who collects the policy.
06
What to do: for heirs and for policyholders
For the family
- Find out whether policies exist. IVASS, the Italian insurance supervisor, points to the life policy search service run by ANIA, the insurers’ association, and to a written request to the bank, intermediary or insurer the relative used. Because the search also checks whether the person asking is named as a beneficiary, every potential beneficiary should make a request.
- Ask for the text of the beneficiary clause. It has to be read together with any will and with the family tree at the time of death, including beneficiaries who died before the policyholder.
- Check the proposed division. If the insurer divides by estate shares, or per head where some beneficiaries had died first, the proposal should be challenged before it is accepted.
- Keep to the time limit. Rights under a life insurance policy are time-barred after ten years (art. 2952 of the Civil Code); according to IVASS, once that period has passed insurers transfer unclaimed sums to the dormant accounts fund held by CONSAP.
For the policyholder
IVASS recommends naming beneficiaries individually rather than using general wording such as “statutory heirs”. Those who prefer general wording can still state the proportions. A designation is revoked or changed in the same forms in which it is made, including by will, but the heirs cannot revoke it after the policyholder’s death (art. 1921 of the Civil Code). In our inheritance and estate work we review policies, wills and shares together, including for families living abroad, before the division turns into a family dispute; you can write to us in English.
Laws and rulings cited
The sources this article relies on, checked against the official text on the date shown.
- Court of Cassation, Civil Section III, judgment of 20 April 2026, no. 10382 (opens in a new window) “Testamentary heirs or, failing them, statutory heirs”: beneficiaries are identified by interpreting the will; recalls Joint Divisions no. 11421/2021.
- Court of Cassation, Civil Section III, order of 8 June 2026, no. 18633 (opens in a new window) Equal shares among heirs as beneficiaries and the predeceased beneficiary’s share to his heirs; recalls the Joint Divisions and no. 5986/2025.
- Civil Code, arts 1920 and 1921 (opens in a new window) Designation of the beneficiary, even in general terms, own right, revocation and its limits.
- Civil Code, art. 1923 (opens in a new window) Payout protected from enforcement; for premiums, creditors’ action, collation and reduction remain.
- Civil Code, art. 1412 (opens in a new window) Benefit paid to the heirs of a beneficiary who dies before the policyholder.
- Civil Code, arts 581 and 588 (opens in a new window) Spouse’s share with children; difference between heir and legatee.
- Civil Code, art. 2952 (opens in a new window) Ten-year limitation for rights under life insurance.
- IVASS, Dormant life insurance policies (opens in a new window) Searching a deceased relative’s policies, dormant accounts fund, advice to name beneficiaries individually.






